Hill Country

30 W. 26th St, NY, NY 10010

Rating: A - Excellent
Visit #: 5
In brief: Even though you have to go through the hostess, into the dining hall and back around out to the cashier and even though the chocolate cookie looked too doughy, it was totally and absolutely worth it. This cookie is all sorts of stellar awesomeness. Worth whatever you have to do to get one.