4:00pm chocolate chip cookie

It's fortunate our Pret a Manger cookie source was not in midtown or even downtown where apparently the Serious Eats surprise pronouncement caused quite a run on the cookies SE just declared the "best in midtown". Personally ours was a bit too sweet, or to put it another way the dark chocolate chips or the dough could have used a touch less sugar. But the dough, ah, yummy with a bit of saltiness, exactly as described by SE.
Pret a Manger, 2 Park Avenue, NY, NY 10016 (btwn 32nd and 33rd)